arthham

JEE Advanced 1984 · Laws of Motion

The pulley arrangements of Figs. (a) and (b) are identical. The mass of the rope is negligible. In (a) the mass m is lifted up by attaching a mass 2m to the other end of the rope. In (b), m is lifted up by pulling the other end of the rope with a constant downward force F=2F = 2mg. The acceleration of m is the same in both cases.

Answer: False

Watch this solved on the board The full walkthrough, written out a line at a time with narration explaining each step as it appears. Pause anywhere and ask why a line is there. Free to watch

Or read the worked solution below. Jump to the steps ↓

Written solution

Step 1: Analyze Case (a).

Apply Newton's second law to the masses mm and 2m2m connected by the massless rope.

T−mg=maaT - mg = ma_a 2mg−T=2maa2mg - T = 2ma_a

Step 2: Calculate the acceleration for Case (a).

Add the two equations of motion to eliminate the tension TT.

mg=3maamg = 3ma_a aa=g3a_a = \frac{g}{3}

Step 3: Analyze Case (b).

Since the rope is massless and the pulley is frictionless, the tension in the rope is equal to the applied pulling force.

T=2mgT = 2mg

Step 4: Calculate the acceleration for Case (b).

Apply Newton's second law to the mass mm.

T−mg=mabT - mg = ma_b 2mg−mg=mab2mg - mg = ma_b ab=ga_b = g

Step 5: Compare the accelerations.

Compare the resulting accelerations from both cases.

aa=g3a_a = \frac{g}{3} ab=ga_b = g aa≠aba_a \neq a_b

Answer: The statement is False. The acceleration in case (a) is g3\dfrac{g}{3}, while the acceleration in case (b) is gg.

More from Laws of Motion

All 40 Laws of Motion questions →

Laws of Motion: formulas and what the chapter covers →