arthham

JEE Advanced 2016 · Units and Measurements

A length-scale (ll) depends on the permittivity (ε\varepsilon) of a dielectric material, Boltzmann constant (kBk_{\text{B}}), the absolute temperature (TT), the number per unit volume (nn) of certain charged particles, and the charge (qq) carried by each of the particles. Which of the following expression(s) for ll is(are) dimensionally correct?

Answers: B. l=εkBTnq2l = \sqrt{\dfrac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{nq^{2}}} · D. l=q2εn1/3kBTl = \sqrt{\dfrac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{1/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}

Watch this solved on the board The full walkthrough, written out a line at a time with narration explaining each step as it appears. Pause anywhere and ask why a line is there. Free to watch

Or read the worked solution below. Jump to the steps ↓

Written solution

Step 1: Identify the dimensions of the given physical quantities.

The dimensions of the length-scale ll, permittivity ε\varepsilon, Boltzmann constant kBk_{\text{B}}, absolute temperature TT, number density nn, and charge qq are determined from their physical definitions.

[l]=L[l] = L [ε]=[q2][F][r2]=M−1L−3T4I2[\varepsilon] = \frac{[q^2]}{[F][r^2]} = M^{-1}L^{-3}T^4 I^2 [kB]=[energy][T]=ML2T−2Θ−1[k_{\text{B}}] = \frac{[\text{energy}]}{[T]} = ML^2 T^{-2} \Theta^{-1} [T]=Θ[T] = \Theta [n]=L−3[n] = L^{-3} [q]=IT[q] = IT

Step 2: Find the dimensions of key combinations.

Determine the dimension of the combination εkBT\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T.

[εkBT]=(M−1L−3T4I2)(ML2T−2Θ−1)(Θ)[\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T] = (M^{-1}L^{-3}T^4 I^2)(ML^2 T^{-2} \Theta^{-1})(\Theta) [εkBT]=L−1T2I2[\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T] = L^{-1}T^2 I^2

Determine the dimension of the combination q2εkBT\dfrac{q^2}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}.

[q2εkBT]=I2T2L−1T2I2\left[\frac{q^2}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}\right] = \frac{I^2 T^2}{L^{-1}T^2 I^2} [q2εkBT]=L\left[\frac{q^2}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}\right] = L

Step 3: Test the dimensional correctness of Option 1.

Check the dimension of the expression nq2εkBT\sqrt{\dfrac{nq^{2}}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}}.

[nq2εkBT]=[n]⋅[q2εkBT]\left[\sqrt{\frac{nq^{2}}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = \sqrt{[n] \cdot \left[\frac{q^2}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}\right]} [nq2εkBT]=L−3⋅L\left[\sqrt{\frac{nq^{2}}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = \sqrt{L^{-3} \cdot L} [nq2εkBT]=L−1≠L\left[\sqrt{\frac{nq^{2}}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = L^{-1} \neq L

Step 4: Test the dimensional correctness of Option 2.

Check the dimension of the expression εkBTnq2\sqrt{\dfrac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{nq^{2}}}.

[εkBTnq2]=1[n]⋅[εkBTq2]\left[\sqrt{\frac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{nq^{2}}}\right] = \sqrt{\frac{1}{[n]} \cdot \left[\frac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{q^2}\right]} [εkBTnq2]=L3⋅L−1\left[\sqrt{\frac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{nq^{2}}}\right] = \sqrt{L^3 \cdot L^{-1}} [εkBTnq2]=L\left[\sqrt{\frac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{nq^{2}}}\right] = L

Step 5: Test the dimensional correctness of Option 3.

Check the dimension of the expression q2εn2/3kBT\sqrt{\dfrac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{2/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}.

[q2εn2/3kBT]=[n−2/3]⋅[q2εkBT]\left[\sqrt{\frac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{2/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = \sqrt{[n^{-2/3}] \cdot \left[\frac{q^2}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}\right]} [q2εn2/3kBT]=L2⋅L\left[\sqrt{\frac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{2/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = \sqrt{L^2 \cdot L} [q2εn2/3kBT]=L3/2≠L\left[\sqrt{\frac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{2/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = L^{3/2} \neq L

Step 6: Test the dimensional correctness of Option 4.

Check the dimension of the expression q2εn1/3kBT\sqrt{\dfrac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{1/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}.

[q2εn1/3kBT]=[n−1/3]⋅[q2εkBT]\left[\sqrt{\frac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{1/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = \sqrt{[n^{-1/3}] \cdot \left[\frac{q^2}{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}\right]} [q2εn1/3kBT]=L⋅L\left[\sqrt{\frac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{1/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = \sqrt{L \cdot L} [q2εn1/3kBT]=L\left[\sqrt{\frac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{1/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}\right] = L

Answer: The dimensionally correct expressions are (2) εkBTnq2\sqrt{\dfrac{\varepsilon k_{\text{B}} T}{nq^{2}}} and (4) q2εn1/3kBT\sqrt{\dfrac{q^{2}}{\varepsilon n^{1/3} k_{\text{B}} T}}.

More from Units and Measurements

All 37 Units and Measurements questions →

Units and Measurements: formulas and what the chapter covers →