JEE Advanced 2008 · Introduction to Three Dimensional Geometry
Consider three planes P1:x−y+z=1; P2:x+y−z=−1P3:x−3y+3z=2
Let L1,L2,L3 be the lines of intersection of the planes P2 and P3, P3 and P1, P1 and P2, respectively.
Statement-I : At least two of the lines L1,L2 and L3 are non-parallel
Statement-II : The three planes do not have a common point.
Answer:D. STATEMENT - I is False, STATEMENT - II is True
Consider three planes P₁ : x - y + z = 1; P₂ : x + y - z = -1 P₃ : x - 3y + 3z = 2 Let L₁, L₂, L₃ be the lines of intersection of the planes P₂ and P₃, P₃ and P₁, P₁ and P₂, respectively. Statement-I : At least two of the lines L₁, L₂ and L₃ are non-parallel Statement-II : The three planes do not have a common point.
P1:x−y+z=1,P2:x+y−z=−1
P3:x−3y+3z=2
L1=P2∩P3,L2=P3∩P1,L3=P1∩P2
Check: S-I (non-parallel?) and S-II (common point?)
1.normals n1,n2,n3
2.dLi=nj×nk⇒S-I
3.consistency of P1,P2,P3⇒S-II
P1:n1=(1,−1,1),P2:n2=(1,1,−1)
P3:n3=(1,−3,3)
dL1=n2×n3=(0,−4,−4)
dL2=n3×n1=(0,2,2)
dL3=n1×n2=(0,2,2)
(0,−4,−4)∥(0,2,2)∥(0,2,2)∥(0,1,1)
⇒L1,L2,L3 all parallel⇒S-I is FALSE
n3=2n1−n2
2P1−P2:2(x−y+z)−(x+y−z)=2(1)−(−1)
⇒x−3y+3z=3=2
common point⇒x−3y+3z=3
but P3:x−3y+3z=2⇒contradiction
⇒no common point⇒S-II is TRUE
P1+P2:2x=0⇒x=0
x=0⇒P1:−y+z=1,P3:−y+z=32
1=32⇒inconsistent
S-I is FALSE, S-II is TRUE
⇒option (4)
More from Introduction to Three Dimensional Geometry