arthham

JEE Advanced 2008 · Work, Energy and Power

The balls, having linear momenta p⃗1=pi^\vec{p}_1 = p\hat{i} and p⃗2=−pi^\vec{p}_2 = -p\hat{i}, undergo a collision in free space. There is no external force acting on the balls. Let p⃗1′\vec{p}_1' and p⃗2′\vec{p}_2' be their final momenta. The following option(s) is(are) NOT ALLOWED for any non-zero value of pp, a1a_1, a2a_2, b1b_1, b2b_2, c1c_1 and c2c_2.

Answers: A. p⃗1′=a1i^+b1j^+c1k^\vec{p}_1' = a_1\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j} + c_1\hat{k} ; p⃗2′=a2i^+b2j^\vec{p}_2' = a_2\hat{i} + b_2\hat{j} · D. p⃗1′=a1i^+b1j^\vec{p}_1' = a_1\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j} ; p⃗2′=a2i^+b1j^\vec{p}_2' = a_2\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j}

Watch this solved on the board The full walkthrough, written out a line at a time with narration explaining each step as it appears. Pause anywhere and ask why a line is there. Free to watch

Or read the worked solution below. Jump to the steps ↓

Written solution

Step 1: Determine the initial total momentum of the system.

Since there is no external force acting on the balls, the total linear momentum of the system is conserved.

p⃗1=pi^\vec{p}_1 = p\hat{i} p⃗2=−pi^\vec{p}_2 = -p\hat{i} P⃗initial=p⃗1+p⃗2=0\vec{P}_{\text{initial}} = \vec{p}_1 + \vec{p}_2 = 0

Step 2: Apply the conservation of linear momentum.

The total final momentum must equal the total initial momentum.

P⃗final=p⃗1′+p⃗2′=0\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = \vec{p}_1' + \vec{p}_2' = 0 p⃗2′=−p⃗1′\vec{p}_2' = -\vec{p}_1'

Step 3: Analyze Option (1).

The final momenta are given as:

p⃗1′=a1i^+b1j^+c1k^\vec{p}_1' = a_1\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j} + c_1\hat{k} p⃗2′=a2i^+b2j^\vec{p}_2' = a_2\hat{i} + b_2\hat{j}

Calculate the total final momentum:

P⃗final=(a1+a2)i^+(b1+b2)j^+c1k^\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = (a_1 + a_2)\hat{i} + (b_1 + b_2)\hat{j} + c_1\hat{k}

Since c1≠0c_1 \neq 0, the k^\hat{k} component of the total momentum can never be zero, violating momentum conservation.

Step 4: Analyze Option (2).

The final momenta are given as:

p⃗1′=c1k^\vec{p}_1' = c_1\hat{k} p⃗2′=c2k^\vec{p}_2' = c_2\hat{k}

Calculate the total final momentum:

P⃗final=(c1+c2)k^\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = (c_1 + c_2)\hat{k}

Choosing c2=−c1c_2 = -c_1 yields P⃗final=0\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = 0, which is allowed.

Step 5: Analyze Option (3).

The final momenta are given as:

p⃗1′=a1i^+b1j^+c1k^\vec{p}_1' = a_1\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j} + c_1\hat{k} p⃗2′=a2i^+b2j^−c1k^\vec{p}_2' = a_2\hat{i} + b_2\hat{j} - c_1\hat{k}

Calculate the total final momentum:

P⃗final=(a1+a2)i^+(b1+b2)j^\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = (a_1 + a_2)\hat{i} + (b_1 + b_2)\hat{j}

Choosing a2=−a1a_2 = -a_1 and b2=−b1b_2 = -b_1 yields P⃗final=0\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = 0, which is allowed.

Step 6: Analyze Option (4).

The final momenta are given as:

p⃗1′=a1i^+b1j^\vec{p}_1' = a_1\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j} p⃗2′=a2i^+b1j^\vec{p}_2' = a_2\hat{i} + b_1\hat{j}

Calculate the total final momentum:

P⃗final=(a1+a2)i^+2b1j^\vec{P}_{\text{final}} = (a_1 + a_2)\hat{i} + 2b_1\hat{j}

Since b1≠0b_1 \neq 0, the j^\hat{j} component of the total momentum can never be zero, violating momentum conservation.

Answer: Options (1) and (4) are NOT ALLOWED.

More from Work, Energy and Power

All 35 Work, Energy and Power questions →