arthham

JEE Advanced 2012 · System of Particles and Rotational Motion

Consider a disc rotating in the horizontal plane with a constant angular speed ω\omega about its centre OO. The disc has a shaded region on one side of the diameter and an unshaded region on the other side as shown in the figure. When the disc is in the orientation as shown, two pebbles PP and QQ are simultaneously projected at an angle towards RR. The velocity of projection is in the yy-zz plane and is same for both pebbles with respect to the disc. Assume that (i) they land back on the disc before the disc has completed 1/81/8 rotation, (ii) their range is less than half the disc radius, and (iii) ω\omega remains constant throughout. Then

Answer: C. Both PP and QQ land in the unshaded region.

Watch this solved on the board The full walkthrough, written out a line at a time with narration explaining each step as it appears. Pause anywhere and ask why a line is there. Free to watch

Or read the worked solution below. Jump to the steps ↓

Written solution

Step 1: Define the coordinate system and initial parameters.

Let the disc lie in the horizontal xx-yy plane, rotating with constant angular velocity ω⃗=ωz^\vec{\omega} = \omega \hat{z} about its center OO. The diameter RR-PP lies along the yy-axis, separating the shaded region (x<0x < 0) from the unshaded region (x>0x > 0).

Both pebbles are projected in the yy-zz plane towards RR with the same relative velocity:

v⃗rel=(0,uy,uz)\vec{v}_{\text{rel}} = (0, u_y, u_z)

Step 2: Determine the initial velocity in the ground frame.

For a pebble projected from a point on the diameter at a distance ρ\rho from the center OO, its initial position vector is r⃗=(0,ρ,0)\vec{r} = (0, \rho, 0). The velocity of this point on the disc is:

v⃗disc=ω⃗×r⃗\vec{v}_{\text{disc}} = \vec{\omega} \times \vec{r} v⃗disc=ωz^×(ρy^)=−ωρx^\vec{v}_{\text{disc}} = \omega \hat{z} \times (\rho \hat{y}) = -\omega \rho \hat{x}

The initial velocity of the pebble in the ground frame is:

v⃗ground=v⃗rel+v⃗disc\vec{v}_{\text{ground}} = \vec{v}_{\text{rel}} + \vec{v}_{\text{disc}} v⃗ground=(−ωρ,uy,uz)\vec{v}_{\text{ground}} = (-\omega \rho, u_y, u_z)

Step 3: Find the landing position in the ground frame.

The time of flight TT is determined solely by the vertical motion and is identical for both pebbles:

T=2uzgT = \frac{2u_z}{g}

In the ground frame, the horizontal coordinates of the landing point after time TT are:

X=−ωρTX = -\omega \rho T Y=ρ+uyTY = \rho + u_y T

Step 4: Transform the landing coordinates to the rotating disc frame.

During the flight, the disc rotates through an angle ϕ=ωT\phi = \omega T. To find the landing position x′x' in the rotating frame of the disc, we rotate the ground coordinates (X,Y)(X, Y) by −ϕ-\phi:

x′=Xcos⁡ϕ+Ysin⁡ϕx' = X \cos\phi + Y \sin\phi x′=−ωρTcos⁡(ωT)+(ρ+uyT)sin⁡(ωT)x' = -\omega \rho T \cos(\omega T) + (\rho + u_y T) \sin(\omega T)

Step 5: Apply small-angle approximations.

Since the flight time is short (T<18T < \frac{1}{8} of a rotation), the angle ϕ=ωT\phi = \omega T is small. Using the Taylor expansions sin⁡ϕ≈ϕ−ϕ36\sin\phi \approx \phi - \frac{\phi^3}{6} and cos⁡ϕ≈1−ϕ22\cos\phi \approx 1 - \frac{\phi^2}{2}:

x′≈−ωρT(1−ω2T22)+(ρ+uyT)(ωT−ω3T36)x' \approx -\omega \rho T \left(1 - \frac{\omega^2 T^2}{2}\right) + (\rho + u_y T) \left(\omega T - \frac{\omega^3 T^3}{6}\right) x′≈−ωρT+12ω3ρT3+ρωT−16ω3ρT3+uyωT2−16uyω3T3x' \approx -\omega \rho T + \frac{1}{2}\omega^3 \rho T^3 + \rho \omega T - \frac{1}{6}\omega^3 \rho T^3 + u_y \omega T^2 - \frac{1}{6} u_y \omega^3 T^3

Simplifying the expression by cancelling the leading terms:

x′≈ωuyT2+13ω3ρT3−16uyω3T3x' \approx \omega u_y T^2 + \frac{1}{3}\omega^3 \rho T^3 - \frac{1}{6} u_y \omega^3 T^3

Since ωT≪1\omega T \ll 1, the dominant term is:

x′≈ωuyT2x' \approx \omega u_y T^2

Since ω>0\omega > 0 and uy>0u_y > 0, we have:

x′>0x' > 0

Alternatively, in the rotating frame of reference, both pebbles experience a Coriolis force in the +x′+x' direction:

F⃗Coriolis=−2m(ω⃗×v⃗rel)\vec{F}_{\text{Coriolis}} = -2m(\vec{\omega} \times \vec{v}_{\text{rel}}) F⃗Coriolis=−2m(ωz^×uyy^)=2mωuyx^\vec{F}_{\text{Coriolis}} = -2m(\omega \hat{z} \times u_y \hat{y}) = 2m\omega u_y \hat{x}

This force deflects both pebbles into the unshaded region.

Answer: Both PP and QQ land in the unshaded region.

More from System of Particles and Rotational Motion

All 46 System of Particles and Rotational Motion questions →