arthham

JEE Advanced 2012 · System of Particles and Rotational Motion

Two solid cylinders PP and QQ of same mass and same radius start rolling down a fixed inclined plane from the same height at the same time. Cylinder PP has most of its mass concentrated near its surface, while QQ has most of its mass concentrated near the axis. Which statement(s) is(are) correct?

Answers: D. Cylinder QQ reaches the ground with larger angular speed.

Watch this solved on the board The full walkthrough, written out a line at a time with narration explaining each step as it appears. Pause anywhere and ask why a line is there. Free to watch

Or read the worked solution below. Jump to the steps ↓

Written solution

Step 1: Analyze the mass distribution and moment of inertia.

Let both cylinders have mass mm and radius RR, and define the dimensionless parameter kk representing the mass distribution.

k=ImR2k = \frac{I}{mR^2}

Since cylinder PP has its mass concentrated near the surface and cylinder QQ has its mass concentrated near the axis, the moment of inertia of PP is greater than that of QQ.

kP>kQk_P > k_Q

Step 2: Compare the linear accelerations.

The acceleration aa of a body rolling down an incline of angle θ\theta without slipping is given by the rolling formula.

a=gsin⁡θ1+ka = \frac{g\sin\theta}{1 + k}

Since kP>kQk_P > k_Q, the denominator for PP is larger, resulting in a smaller acceleration.

aP<aQa_P < a_Q

Thus, statement (2) is false.

Step 3: Compare the times taken to reach the bottom.

For a distance ss along the incline starting from rest, the time tt is related to the acceleration.

s=12at2s = \frac{1}{2}at^2 t=2sat = \sqrt{\frac{2s}{a}}

Since aP<aQa_P < a_Q, the time taken by PP is greater than that of QQ.

tP>tQt_P > t_Q

Thus, statement (1) is false.

Step 4: Compare the translational kinetic energies at the bottom.

Using conservation of energy, the loss in potential energy equals the gain in total kinetic energy.

mgh=12mv2+12Iω2mgh = \frac{1}{2}mv^2 + \frac{1}{2}I\omega^2

Using the rolling without slipping condition v=ωRv = \omega R, express the total energy in terms of kk.

mgh=12mv2(1+k)mgh = \frac{1}{2}mv^2(1+k)

Solve for the translational kinetic energy.

KEtrans=12mv2\text{KE}_{\text{trans}} = \frac{1}{2}mv^2 KEtrans=mgh1+k\text{KE}_{\text{trans}} = \frac{mgh}{1+k}

Since kP>kQk_P > k_Q, the translational kinetic energy of PP is less than that of QQ.

(KEtrans)P<(KEtrans)Q(\text{KE}_{\text{trans}})_P < (\text{KE}_{\text{trans}})_Q

Thus, statement (3) is false.

Step 5: Compare the angular speeds at the bottom.

Express the linear velocity at the bottom of the incline.

v=2gh1+kv = \sqrt{\frac{2gh}{1+k}}

The angular speed is related to the linear velocity.

ω=vR\omega = \frac{v}{R} ω=1R2gh1+k\omega = \frac{1}{R}\sqrt{\frac{2gh}{1+k}}

Since kQ<kPk_Q < k_P, the angular speed of QQ is greater than that of PP.

ωQ>ωP\omega_Q > \omega_P

Thus, statement (4) is true.

Answer: Only statement (4) is correct: Cylinder QQ reaches the bottom with a larger angular speed than cylinder PP (ωQ>ωP\omega_Q > \omega_P).

More from System of Particles and Rotational Motion

All 46 System of Particles and Rotational Motion questions →